Updated November 9, 2026
I first wrote this post after reading The 4 Disciplines of Execution. Its terms, such as "Wildly Important Goals," "lead measures," "scoreboards," and a "cadence of accountability," are good ones. But underneath, the concept is a refresh of something from Quality 101: the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle.
If you work in manufacturing, you already know PDCA. It's built into your quality system. What most companies never do is run their marketing the same way.
Effective marketing is no different than manufacturing a part or delivering a service.
"If you can't measure it, you can't manage it.
If you can't manage it, you can't improve it."
The American Society for Quality describes PDCA as "a four-step model for carrying out change" that, like a circle, has no end. You repeat it for continuous improvement.
Credit goes to Walter Shewhart and W. Edwards Deming. According to the W. Edwards Deming Institute, Deming learned the cycle from Shewhart at Bell Laboratories. Deming himself preferred Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA), because "study" means learning from the results, not just checking pass or fail. I like that distinction for marketing. A missed goal is only a failure if you don't learn anything from it.
PDCA is still part of the world's most widely used quality standard. ISO 9001:2026, published September 16, 2026, describes the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle in clause 0.3.2 and says it can be applied to all processes and to the quality management system as a whole. That includes the processes that bring in new customers.
Before you plan anything, remember what quality means. Philip Crosby put it simply: quality is conformance to requirements. ISO 9001 puts the customer's requirements at the center of the process approach.
For marketing, the customer's requirements are things like:
If you make it hard to do business with you, a competitor who makes it easy will win the job, and may charge more for it.
Every good plan starts with knowing where you stand.
To measure something, you have to do something.
You use production scheduling in your plant. Use the same discipline for marketing: a content calendar, clear owners, and due dates. A CRM like HubSpot can manage the tasks and the calendar in one place.
Two rules for the Do step:
Did you meet your goal? Simple question. Simple answer. Yes or no.
That only works if the goal was clear to begin with. That's why we use SMART goals:
When you check, compare like with like: the same length of time before and after the change, and the same period last year if your business is seasonal. And check the metric that matters. Traffic going up while quote requests stay flat isn't a win.
Then go back to Plan. The cycle never ends. That's the point.
Here's how the cycle looks for an ISO-certified machine shop that wants more quote requests from its website.
| Step | What they do |
|---|---|
| Plan | GA4 shows plenty of visits to the capabilities page but few quote requests. Hypothesis: buyers can't find tolerances, materials, and certifications fast enough. SMART goal: increase quote form submissions from the capabilities page from 4 to 8 per month by March 31. |
| Do | Add a specs table, an ISO 9001 certification section, and a "Request a Quote" button above the fold, on that one page only. Annotate the change date in GA4. |
| Check | After 60 days, compare quote form key events from the page with the 60 days before the change. |
| Act | If quote requests went up, apply the same layout to the other capability pages. If not, test a different hypothesis, such as a shorter form or adding lead times. |
PDCA works especially well for SEO because Google Search Console gives you a built-in scoreboard.
| Step | What they do |
|---|---|
| Plan | Search Console shows a service page with 3,000 impressions but a 0.5% click-through rate in the last 3 months. Hypothesis: the title tag doesn't match what searchers are looking for. SMART goal: raise the page's click-through rate to 1.5% within 90 days. |
| Do | Rewrite the title tag and meta description to match the page's top queries. Add a Search Console annotation on the date it goes live. |
| Check | Compare clicks, impressions, and click-through rate for the 28 days before and after the change, and check whether average position moved. |
| Act | If click-through rate improved, apply the same approach to the next five pages with high impressions and low clicks. If it didn't, test a new title, or look at whether the page content matches the search intent. |
One cycle won't transform your search traffic. Twelve cycles a year, each one teaching you something, will.
Put this into practice with our free PDCA Marketing Worksheet. It's a one-page Excel template with a SMART goal builder, a Plan-Do-Check-Act log, and a before-and-after results table.
Download the PDCA Marketing Worksheet
Want help running your marketing like a quality system?
We help manufacturers and service businesses set measurable goals, track the results that matter, and improve them cycle after cycle.
Book a time to talk with Phil.